Enterprise Ecommerce / How to Sell Online

7 Tips to Find the Perfect 3PL for Your Fulfillment Network

Nate Kristy / 5 min read

Outsourcing ecommerce warehousing to a third party logistics provider (3PL) has many benefits for a scaling business. Not only are these providers experts on all of the necessary operational tasks –– hiring warehouse workers, maintaining equipment, paying rent, keeping track of pallets, etc. –– but in many cases, these 3PLs can complete those tasks quicker, cheaper and more efficiently than you could in your own warehouse.

On average, using a 3PL can reduce fixed and variable logistics costs as well as inventory costs.

Third party providers address storage, transport and handling needs on behalf of client companies. They then use sophisticated software to develop a warehousing management and distribution plan that will best suit the needs of each company whose products they store.

All ready to sign up? Think carefully –– committing to a 3PL relationship is not a decision to take lightly. A 3PL has to fit well with your business operations, growth plans and customer service culture, because the services stipulated in a third party warehousing contract are generally performed on a long term basis. Once you are on board with one, it’s tough to disengage. A 3PL should be both a solutions provider and an adviser that you can trust. They should be thinking of creative ways to make sure that your products are brought to market faster and cheaper. To do so, they will need a complete understanding of all your present and future fulfillment needs.

We’ve developed our own short list of important considerations.

1. What is the 3PL’s level of technological sophistication?

Why can it take a 3PL so long to make a process change or enable a new process in response to a customer request? The answer is simply that they have many clients in a complex business. To the greatest extent possible, a 3PL wants to share processes across their customer base. That is much easier than trying to adapt to 30 different unique customer logistics scenarios. One of your challenges will be to make sure that your 3PL is keeping pace with the rapid and ongoing changes occurring in technology, and that its IT strategy and roadmap align with yours.

How? Look at how much the company invests in technology annually as a percent of net revenues. Then, dig deeper. What you really want to know is how much of a 3PL’s annual IT budget goes toward innovation-related projects — i.e. toward developing or implementing new applications or functionality, especially customer-facing solutions, not just maintaining legacy systems.

Confirm that the capabilities of the 3PL’s systems are able to integrate with your own automation requirements such as your order routing and storefront inventory management tools, plus any accounting or CRM requirements.

2. Can the 3PL keep pace with your growth?

Chances are the answer is “yes.” Flexibility and scalability are key. Your 3PL needs to be able to handle your current requirements, as well as the requirements your business will have as it continues to grow. Ideally, you want to have a 3PL that can immediately take on that extra inventory. If your business plans to reach new markets, it is also necessary for the 3PL to be able to expand along with you. To meet these flexibility needs, a 3PL should work very closely with clients to understand their planning and forecasting, and in reponse, deliver in terms of labor and support services.

Short term, a 3PL must be able to help companies manage peak seasons, such as the holiday rush for the retail sector. Clients need to be able to surge their supply chains so that they can get to market with precision and timing. Then, when the peak season is over, scale back down and not have those carrying costs in their supply chain.

3. How strong is the 3PL financially?

This is a question you should ask of any potential partner, but this is especially the case since 3PLs are capital-intensive businesses. Historically, they have funded operating costs, lease commitments and capital investments. A 3PL that is not financially stable may be focused on its own economic situation rather than helping you improve your business. Financially healthy partners should have the resources to invest in you as a client, and in their own operational capabilities, to provide the customer service you require.

Do your 3PL partners have the financial stability to weather significant disruptions, especially when access to capital is more restricted? And, are they in a good position to take advantage of innovations that will both protect and advance your business? Strong cash flow is the most important indicator of financial health.

Ask the 3PL for their profit and loss data covering the past few years so you can look for any trends that will help you to make your decision. Along with being financially healthy, check to see that the 3PL has solid relationships with banks and stable leadership.

4. Is the 3PL prepared for disasters?

Supply chain disruptions significantly affect your bottom line, so you should know how your 3PL partner is positioned to deal with them on the logistics side. Despite the increased risk of supply chain disruption, many companies are currently underfunding disruption-mitigation planning. Ask about internal planning for disaster preparedness, labor shortages/stoppages, technology outages, weather-related transportation disruptions and other risks particular to your product line.

5. How deep is the 3PL’s talent?

There is currently a shortage of supply chain and logistics talent in the industry, and it’s arguably the biggest issue facing both 3PLs and their clients. When choosing a supply chain partner for third party logistics, factor in the overall breadth and depth of experience within its staff. The amount of knowledge and expertise in warehousing and transportation among this potential partner’s management team and staff as a whole can have a significant impact (positive or negative) on business.

How deep is the 3PL’s talent pool? Will the replacement be as competent and have the same communication and relationship management skills as the previous person? Does the 3PL have a defined succession planning process that involves the client to ensure a smooth transition? Also, ask what kind of investments the 3PL has been making — and plans to make — in employee training.

6. Do they offer business intelligence and solutions beyond the basics?

This point goes beyond IT. Savvy 3PLs are introducing their ecommerce clients to related technology providers, providing insights about industry-leading practices and trends, and facilitating networking and knowledge-exchange opportunities with other shippers in the 3PL’s community.

Does your 3PL conduct market research and share its findings with you? Do they organize peer-to-peer learning and networking events for clients and industry experts to attend? Do they make it easy for you to contact and collaborate with their extended team of experts and partners?

7. How do they stand on your needs and metrics that matter most?

Be sure to research and compare your potential 3PLs objectively against the metrics that matter most to your business. Objectively document your findings (here’s an Excel-based 3PL evaluation scorecard that is popular with our clients). Ask evaluation questions such as:

  • How do they manage stock rotation parameters?
  • How will they handle identification of a product’s location in the event of a recall?
  • Are they able to show ongoing cost and process improvements?
  • What is their lead time to respond to changes in order volume or origin/destination and stocking levels?

You also need to confirm that they have the necessary experience and flexibility to accommodate, or at least not interrupt, your business requirements outside of your direct relationship. For example, if you anticipate fulfilling future orders through both this new 3PL and your current network of dropshippers, make sure that your new 3PL’s processes (data requirements, etc.) don’t prohibit you from doing so. It can be incredibly frustrating to find out after the fact that all of your business’ integrated and automated processes need to be completely redesigned due to the unanticipated requirements of a newly contracted 3PL.

In all, a 3PL can be a huge time and budget saver for scaling businesses, just be sure not to commit to anything you haven’t fully researched.


Nate Kristy

Nate Kristy

Nate Kristy leads marketing for HubLogix, the Atlanta, Georgia-based ecommerce automation company that drives profits through efficiency in the worldwide supply chain. Through their technology – including the order lifecycle management platform – they connect online retailers to their distributors and supply chain technologies to automate order management processes from checkout to delivery. A pioneer in ecommerce technology, HubLogix has cut fulfillment costs and created competitive advantages for thousands of thriving online retailers, distribution partners and technology providers since 2010.

View all posts by Nate Kristy

5 comments on “7 Tips to Find the Perfect 3PL for Your Fulfillment Network

  1. Felipe Liberman on

    We sold home decor online for about 10 years. As we grew, our shipping volume also increased while our shipping costs decreased. After a while we decided it would be a great business to get into the shipping business and help online retailers by sharing our knowledge. We have been helping out ecommerce players of all sizes for the past 4 years through our company http://www.shipstandard.com

  2. Tracey Wallace
    Tracey Wallace on

    Thanks for all the info here Serkan! Sounds like you’ve followed the Tim Ferris idea of opening up shop in a niche you’d spent a bunch of money in — and doing it better :) Great advice here!

  3. Serkan Yıldız on

    Thank you! It’s an amazing article. Yes there is too much to consider to decide whether your business should work with 3PLs or not. When I was selling online ( until Amazon jumped into my field and lowered the profits incredibly ) , I always thought if I should go with one of those 3PL companies such as shipwire red flag, fufillment etc. But I not only found them expensive, i also considered the fact that i can’t handle my returns and decide whether items are resellable or if I should dispose them. This was my number one reason that I decided to handle my shipping. Secondly, there was enough opportunity for me to lower my shipping cost ,even with my small volume. I was actually shipping the same product cheaper than those big companies because I was able to customize my packaging.
    To make a long story short, I came up with a new idea to open a ” customized 3PL ” I accept a limited number of customers in order to provide a fully customized service for their needs and also to keep a higher level of service.
    My suggestion is for those selling under 10 per day is to keep shipping on their own but after 20 orders per day they should start to consider outsourcing their logistics. This will free up their time to focus on marketing and sourcing new products and they will actually save money if they can find the right company for their needs.

    Thanks & Regards,
    Serkan Yildiz
    Fbawarehousing.com Prep & Ship and Customized 3PL Order Fulfillment.

  4. Excelsior PH on

    Outsourcing to 3rd party logistics is a very good thing to do, but the financial side should be considered first before making the move. There a lot of things you can cut using the 3PL but there must be price consideration first. Thanks for sharing this post. For more info on logistics, visit us at: https://excelsior.ph/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Less Development. More Marketing.

Let us future-proof your backend. You focus on building your brand.